Marc Morehouse

Hi, I'm Marc Morehouse. I've covered sports for more than 15 years, mostly in Eastern Iowa. I've had Hayden Fry [...]
Updated: 1 February 2013 | 12:39 pm in Hawkeye Football, On Iowa by Marc Morehouse

Notes from HawkeyeReport.com…

Hawkeyes zero in on six prospects for who knows how many spots


thegazette.com Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Dunbar (5) QB Kyler Dawson is pressured by Simeon (5) LB Reggie Spearman in first half action. Dawson was called for intentional grounding on the play. Dunbar plays Simeon in their football game played at Gately Stadium at 103rd and Corliss, Chicago, IL on Friday night 10/5/12.|Judy Fidkowski~For Sun-Times Media

The national signing period starts next Wednesday.

Here is where Iowa sits:

– The Hawkeyes have 16 known commitments and have between one and four known scholarship openings.

– Don’t be shocked if Iowa ends up with 20 or 21 signees.

– Don’t be shocked if Iowa’s class is rated 10th or lower in the Big Ten by the various recruiting services. Iowa’s class was basically built in August. Since, it’s lost two four-star recruits and hasn’t been in the news much.

– That whole four-star thing? Yes, Iowa and Minnesota are the lone Big Ten teams without a four-star recruit, according to Rivals.com.

But . . .

Iowa has 16 three-star commitments going into this weekend, the final for visits. In my opinion, Iowa has six legit targets in play — LB Reggie Spearman (three stars), WR Cameron Smith (three stars), CB/S Jacquille Veii (two stars), WR A.J. Jones (two stars), linebacker Josey Jewell (two stars) and WR Dre Fuller (two stars). BTW, Jones is visiting Iowa City this weekend.

If Iowa sticks at 16, the average of 3.0 stars will be its highest average in the last five years. If Iowa picks up all five from the above, that would bring the average to 2.85, which would rank it fourth in the last five seasons.

Here’s the stars breakdown as it stands now (according to Rivals.com):

2013 — 3.0 stars

2012 — 2.95 stars

2011 — 2.96 stars

2010 — 2.95

2009 — 2.45

I kept misspelling “stars” into “starts,” which might be the better overall measure of a class. I’ll work on that.

Here’s HawkeyeReport.com publisher Tom Kakert with a post on the history of the final pieces of classes for the Hawkeyes. Iowa has found some gems late in the game:

Last weekend was the final push for the Kirk Ferentz and his staff to finish up their recruiting efforts with prospects outside the state of Iowa.

This weekend is the final push to land prospects from the state of Iowa, mostly walk-on’s to the Hawkeye program.

One of the neat things that Ferentz has done consistently in his tenure is reward an in-state prospect late in the recruiting process with a scholarship offer.  While Ferentz may have his detractors for the win/loss record in recent years, this is a really nice thing he does for an in-state prospect and in many cases, it’s worked out rather well for the Hawkeyes.

It really started back with the Class of 2001 when Ferentz made a last minute offer to Mike Elgin, who turned out to be a multiple year starter and spent time in the NFL with the New England Patriots. In 2004, Ferentz called Prairie City-Monroe prep standout Brandon Myers the night before signing day and extended a scholarship offer. Myers was all set to head to Northern Iowa, but made the switch at the last minute. He went on to be an All Big Ten selection and just finished up his best year in the NFL with the Oakland Raiders with 79 receptions for 806 yards and 4 touchdowns.

In 2007, Marion’s Allen Reisner was getting ready for his high school basketball game when Kirk Ferentz called the night before signing day to offer him a scholarship, which he immediately accepted. Reisner has gone on to play in the NFL. In 2009, Wellman-Mid Prairie prep star Tanner Miller was in a similar situation to Reisner, riding home on the bus from a basketball game with his high school team when he picked up an offer from the Hawkeyes. He has gone on to be a three year starter for the Hawkeyes.

This weekend the visitors to Iowa City on the final weekend before signing day will be walk-on heavy, with the potential that maybe one will end up picking up a late offer from the Iowa coaches. The in-state prospects visiting this weekend include Trev Hadacheck from Union High School, Jake Hulett from Springville High School, Cody Poock and Paul Brown from Spirit Lake High School, and Drake Kulick from Muscatine High School. (Kulick announced Thursday night that he would accept a preferred walk-on offer with the Hawkeyes.)

Another in-state name to watch leading up to signing day is Decorah prep Josey Jewell. He will not be visiting this weekend, but he might be the next prospect on the board to get an offer if Iowa has one available on the night before signing day.

The prospects from the Hawkeye state won’t be the only players making their official visits this weekend. Iowa will be hosting two star athlete A.J. Jones from Dallas, TX. The 6-foot-3 and 195 pound athlete was offered by the Hawkeyes this week after he backed out on a visit to Iowa late last week. Jones, who is verbally committed to Colorado State, was also weighing a visit to Texas Tech.

Also visiting this weekend as out of state potential walk-on candidates are Kyle Norberg and Kevin Ward from the state of Illinois. Norberg is a fullback prospect with FCS offers after rushing for over 2,000 yards last season. Ward is the younger brother of current Hawkeye Ryan Ward. He is also looking at potentially walking on at Northwestern, where the oldest Ward child, Patrick, recently wrapped up his college career.

The Hawkeyes current sit at 16 verbal commitments after picking up a pledge this past weekend from defensive back Desmond King from Michigan. The three star prospect was previously committed to Ball State, but made the switch to Iowa on his official visit last weekend.

With three or four more spots left, the best guess heading into the final weekend of recruiting is Iowa ends up picking up three star linebacker Reggie Spearman from Illinois (currently a soft verbal to the Illini), A.J. Jones, and I see a late offer going to Josey Jewell. If they end up landing four more, then my best guess is a late offer goes to Dre Fuller from Texas, who is a speedy wide receiver.

Rules of Engagement
  • Be truthful. more
  • Be civil. more
  • Be responsible. more
  • Own your words. more
  • Leave the trolls alone. more
  • Take commercial ads elsewhere. more
  • Know that comments will be moderated. more
  • Or what? more
Notes from HawkeyeReport.com…
  1. Is there anything in sports analysis that is more random and crapshoot than the star system for recruits?
    Especially when you get down to the 1,2 and 3 star guys.

    • It’s a given measure in a world of no sure things.

      Yes, it’s a crap shoot.

      Micah Hyde was a two-star. Dan Doering was a five-star. Certainly no certainties.

      • No certainties for indiviuals, but look back 3 and 4 years ago to who had the best classes and you’ll see the top of the polls looking right back at you. Likewise look back 3 and 4 years of our classes and you see 50-70th ranked groups and then everyone is shocked by 4-8.

        All the KF lovers out there can come up with names of 2 star recruits that went on to be great, and we love them for it. However, for every Micah Hyde there are 10 2-star recruits that never even see the field. Yes we can have some diamonds in the rough, but you have to go through a lot of “rough” to get one…….one does not win many games……maybe 4 a year.

  2. This just in….
    Tulsa RB commit, Jonathan Parker is visiting this weekend too. He would be a nice fit.
    And while this year’s class may not have all the pizazz that one would like to see, just remember, we have two 4☆’s already in the fold for 2014. 2014 is the key year for recruiting at Iowa.

    • Greg:

      We had two 4* stars early in 2013′s class too – but none will be signing with the Hawks this week; in today’s recruiting world, most recruits don’t fully understand the word “commitment”. When schools like Iowa – schools that only get one to three 4*’s a season – lose them, it makes for much tougher sledding on the field unless we find out some of those 2*-3*’s are heavily underrated…..

  3. We had two four stars this year too, but hey way to be positive.

  4. Say what you want about star ratings being flawed. You don’t see Alabama, Ohio st, or Oklahoma developing a consistent level of success by looking for diamonds in rough. Not saying iowa can recruit to that level but they have to do better than they are doing.

  5. In poker a person holding a pair of 7′s beats a person holding a pair of Aces every once in a while if they get lucky enough to draw another 7. But the odds are against it. It would be nice if this program wasn’t relying on luck to draw another 7. Iowa football has a lot to offer, someone needs to do a better job of selling it. We need to win this year badly for recruiting sake.

    • By the way from what my buddies who play lots of poker say, a pair of Aces gets you beat…A LOT!!!!!!

      • So does your friend do better when he has a pair of 7′s?
        No question KF and/or his staff have done a great job of developing players to be NFL Roster/Practice Team ready. When you compare just those raw numbers they are right up there with all of the top college programs like USC, Texas, Alabama, etc. But if you dig a little deeper and look at NFL starters Iowa is still well represented but they fall back a little.
        I think we all agree that these recruiting stars are determined mostly by guys who have never coached or maybe never even played the game. But if you have ever went to a high school game and seen an elite player you don’t have to be a coach to realize that they are a man among boys. In “most” cases if a 2-star guy and a 4-star guy have the same work ethic and receive the same quality of coaching the 4-star is going to outperform the 2-star. Exceptions are late bloomers or small school players with limited exposure (ie; Greenway, Gallery, Clark).

        Lets face it, like it or not, college football is half recruiting, half coaching. If either one of those falters your team is in trouble. If stars don’t matter to Iowa why do they offer all the 4 and 5 star guys but not all of the 2-3 star guys? Don’t fool yourself KF wants those guys he just can’t get them.

        • Ur kidding right…….I guess we are study different things….Im not going to dig real deep here but I instinctively know that many of these NFL factors (USC imeadetely comes to mind) have had a lot od kids who came in as studs and become those roster fillers that you so shallowly mentioned. Its those that actually provide the back bone of your deep playoff runs….Anyone know where Gren Bay is…I know, at home because they have no depth.

          Incidentally of Iowa’s 32 I count 18 who have or do start and many of those have won some sort of reward. All-rookie, All conference, pro bowl etc….

          Bama on the other hand has Julio Jones and Trent Richardson who has a nice start…but so did Heisman trophy Mark Ingram who is in a 4 back rotation in New Orleans. Lots of examples on both sides of this deal…Iowa is producing talent, what they need to win is some more dominant D-linemen (most of ours have been 2 or 3 stars) and a Qb who has some moxy…..

          I really shouldnt have got in this thread, its always the same.

          Chad

          • Chad. Just curious, what is your source for the 32 and 18 numbers? Why so upset, I’m not really arguing? Again KF is offering the 4 & 5 star guys. He wants them he just isn’t getting them! But he does have a good start for next year as long as we don’t have another 4-8 season.

          • ESPN and my head….and yes KF has offered those kids every year and every year hasnt gotten them…its not new…same formula only our “averag” has gone up and our results down….?!?!?!

          • Thanks Chad for the ESPN info. I checked it out. Very interesting. Iowa is very competitive in numbers with about everyone except USC. So what that tells me again is that the Iowa staff is extremely good at developing players to be NFL ready but must be extremely bad at game-planning. Because with all of those NFL players a good coaching staff should be winning a lot more games.

          • Aaah yes and ironically so should USC, eh?!?! This is why I enjoy these threads…easy to run it around in circles…no easy answers eh coach?!

  6. Really, really missing the point if your concern is where these guys are rated?! I know most of you cats get tired of hearing about Bob Sanders and Gallery so lets not talk about them…

    Iowa currently has 14 2-star/walkons in the NFL…..out of 32 total. Soooooo although Im not prepared to say their recruting is “great” based on results. I would go so far as to say as our “star” ratings have improved over the years are results have trended downward. So you cats who snag onto Ohio St and Bama and Texas, lets remember, EVERY single year they recruit like this and have for eons…..yet here was Bamas record until Saban got there….

    6-7, 10-2, 4-9, 10-3, 7-5, 3-8, 10-3, 7-5, 4-7, ETC, ETC….wildly inconsistent. So really its tired and not germane to Iowa in the least. We have issues for sure, but to pick on the recruting that has lead us to the 12th or 14th most talent in the NFL just shows we dont have any more clue what to fix than the coaches.

    Sometimes its fleeting…to me, based on the amount of close games weve lost in recnet years its very minute things like execution and attitude. We no longer have that Iowa attitude. The recruting angst gets really tiresome….

    Chad

    • Chad:

      Excellent points! There’s just one thing: close games in college football are won by playmakers and/or intuitive,strong game management. Iowa has had little of that for most of the past 8 seasons. Yes, the attitude has changed over time – it’s changed and disappeared with each close-game loss = especially to lower-talented teams. Otherwise, you’re correct – Iowa doesn’t need a team full of 4-5*’s = they just need a few to put them over the top.

      • Id probbly settle for some Shonn Greens and Pat Angerers and Dallas Clarks and Chad Greenways and Charles Godfreys and Bradley Fletchers and Amari Spieveys and Kevin Kaspers and, and , and…….

        • All those names you mention have been terrific Hawks. While it’s fun to see former Hawks in The League on Sundays, I’m far more concerned about wins on Saturdays first. One thing I enjoy asking people who broach the “NFL talent development” program: with all that NFL “cred”, why isn’t recruiting just a little bit easier – especially when it comes to getting a just a playmaker or two (we will never get the 8-9 of the elite programs , nor would I expect them to)? Why aren’t there a few more victories to show for it?

          • LOL…..u dont say….well one thing I always enjoy asking people that ask that question is why hasnt Texas won 10 straight national championships or USC or, or, or….i/e: poor line of questioning and not easy to sum up?! What else do you like to ask Mike? :-)

            Right now Texas is in a simialr rut as us, with a hall of fame coach and top 10 recruting class after top 10 recruiting class…again very poor arguement that runs over a cliff with example after example after example to back it up.

            Chad

          • Ah, Chad…so dismissive yet so quick to gloss over the facts. The facts include that the elite – both with superior talent AND often superior in-game coaching/management – are contenders for the NC and have longer sustained runs of excellence. Do I expect Iowa to be a NC contender each year? Nope. Do I expect better than what has been shown on the field for much of the last 8 years? Yup. You love to talk about “circular arguments” but you bring nothing more definitive than I to the table.

            The facts remain: Iowa has underachieved in a majority of seasons beginning in 2005. For all the talk of NFL talent coming out of IC, their record certainly doesn’t reflect it. The arguments about execution, in-game coaching deficiencies, recruiting, etc. all come back to the same plate: Kirk Ferentz’s. One thing is almost guaranteed for now: KF will have AT LEAST 3 more seasons to “rebuild” the program AGAIN. I truly hope he does, but history is NOT on his side – but he DID do it once before, so hopefully he can turn it around again.

  7. Actually, if you want to be successful and your watchword is “execution”, then you had better have superior personnel to pull it off. Especially when you run the most predictable offense and defense in all of college football. Get used to sub .500 football until we get some of those superior players.

    • Can u say…brain washed group think…its funny, they talk about processes and execution in every board room and training seminar in America yet when it comes to football it offends you guys……its ALL about execution!!!!!

      I can watch any game and predict whats coming with regularity..and in fact spread offenses its even easier…..play action and formation is the unpredictable factor. Maybe you guys just dont watch much football outsie of Iowa….?!?!

  8. Ill add even more….in baseball, the team who hits the best, fields the best and throws the best or at least the best combination of all 3 typically wins. In basketball, the team that shoots the best and defends the best typically wins…..everyone always knows whats going to happen. There are very few surprises. In fact if you are counting on tricking people to win its going to be a short tenure as coach But for some reason that escapes sound logic it pi&$es people off when it comes to their favorite sports team/

    Finally…if you saw anything on either side of the ball for Iowa football this year that looked normal or typical, PLEASE POINT IT OUT TO ME….We were out of psition, we had to blitz more than ever, play more nickel and dime than ever and it showed on the amount of big plays we gave up.

    Honestly where do people place their logic when they analyze their favorite sports teams..its not just our fans. We joke at work all the time about the ridiculous calls that come on the radio.

    Listen we sucked but if you cant see the execution is heinous then you also dont realise when it gets better thats when will will start winning again.

    • Execution is a great thing when you have the talent to make a difference. My grandmother could execute perfectly but that doesn’t mean she could win a football game. When you run a sweep it is easier for a guy who can run a 4.4 to execute than a guy who runs a 4.6. It is easier to execute a pass completion to a WR who is 6’4″ and runs a 4.4 than to a guy who is 5’11′ and runs a 4.6. Alex Smith actually executes better than Collin Kaepernick but it is raw talent that makes Kaepernick a better QB (And I know he wasn’t a 5-star recruit).

      • Holy snikes are you kidding me…what a rotten, broken down analogy. Wes Welker runs about 4.7 and is 4 feet tall. The best Rbers in the nfl are hardly the fastest and Alex Smith hardly executes a game plan better than AlKapernick. All I can say is we are really, really fortunate you nor any of these others recruit or game plan for us….sheesh!

  9. I personally don’t care whether ANY Iowa player makes it to the NFL, if they do – well good for them! Simply knowing that Iowa had NFL talent doesn’t take any edge off consistently losing games, if anything it just makes the team look that much more sad – losing with NFL talent.

    With the coaching staff, facilities, and BUDGET in place, there is really no excuse for off seasons other than catastrophic issues – like major injuries to key players. That wasn’t the case last year, although coaching changes were significant – so if that is what Iowa wants to hang its hat on as the reason why they had a losing season…

    I think the NFL draft is a lot like college recruiting. The first rounders are not always the studs (a number of them are complete busts), but if you play the percentages, a majority are very, very good. So, that is why you got teams with high recruiting continually reloading each year with great players – yea some of their top talent isn’t going to pan out, most will.

    Iowa reloads with good, and sometimes questionable talent, and that is why they need to play inferior competition to help them better evaluate their players and perhaps even some of their coaches.




Featured Jobs from corridorcareers.com