Marc Morehouse

Hi, I'm Marc Morehouse. I've covered sports for more than 15 years, mostly in Eastern Iowa. I've had Hayden Fry [...]
Updated: 7 November 2012 | 4:27 pm in On Iowa by Marc Morehouse

Three and Out . . .

Fourth-and-no debate, Hope takes some swings, the juco thing


thegazette.com Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Iowa head coach Kirk Ferentz waits to congratulate players as they come off the field during the second half of their NCAA college football game against Indiana at Memorial Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 3, 2012, in Bloomington, Ind. Indiana won, 24-21. (Jim Slosiarek, The Gazette-KCRG)

1) Fourth-and-no debate — When Kirk Ferentz sent the punt team out last week at Indiana, he knew what was coming. Iowa faced fourth-and-1, about two feet maybe, and after officials called for a review, Ferentz put away thoughts of a quick sneak and immediately went with punt.

It was the first question in the postgame. It was a question again Tuesday. Ferentz said it was his call to look for the sneak and his call to pull the plug.

The message to the players? Well, the O-line was ready to go.

“We talked about it in the meeting rooms [this week],” offensive tackle Matt Tobin said. ” ‘How geeked up were you to take off?’ We were all ready to go and then they held it back. It was a tough situation.”

But everyone has a boss and most people have to do what their boss says. In football, that’s 99.96 percent true.

Earlier this season, Iowa went for it on a fourth-and-1 at Michigan State. It turned out to be a score in a double-overtime victory. Ferentz makes the call on these. Game clock, field position and distance are elements that go into the decision.

Last week, it was a decision of defense over offense, with the idea the defense had a better chance at forcing a three-and-out or a turnover than the offense had at gaining six inches.

Given the way it’s gone for the offense this season, is there even a right answer here?

2) Hope takes some swings — For last week’s Penn State game, the number of scanned tickets to enter Purdue’s Ross-Ade Stadium was 23,432, according to the Lafayette (Ind.) Journal and Courier. The stadium holds 60,000. The Boilermakers have lost five straight going into today’s matchup with the Hawkeyes. The athletics director, Morgan Burke, has issued a statement.

It doesn’t look good for coach Danny Hope, who’s in his fourth season and has a 19-27 record. He responded to critics this week.

“Obviously the fans have a reason to be disappointed — we’re very, very disappointed — but I don’t let someone who demonstrates himself in a small way set me back a whole lot,” Hope said. “Certainly, I wouldn’t let someone that has that small character take my happiness away, I assure you that. It wouldn’t be worth it, so it would be beneath me.”

And . . .

“A lot of people who are judgmental to the players are people who never really have enough substance to come close to accomplishing what the players have in their athletic lives,” he said. “Consider the source. That’s the message we send to our team. We want to focus on winning and having a successful season and being winners. It’s hard to focus on that if you’re focused on losers on the outside looking in.”

Purdue won’t lack for motivation this week.

3) The whole juco thing — It’s not that Ferentz is closed to the idea of junior-college transfers. Quite the opposite, actually. Iowa brought in QB Cody Sokol and OL Eric Simmons last January.

Trends do say, however, that Iowa prefers four-year players. Going by the makeup of the five classes on this year’s team: In 2011, Iowa signed OL Dan Heiar, who left the team. Before that, you have to go back to ’08 for another juco, RB Nate Guillory, who also left the team.

“The reality of it is, and I’m going off my history at this school, junior college players don’t, as a rule, always transition in as well,” Ferentz said. “That hasn’t been our mode. but there are some schools where it’s probably more workable.”

The regional comparison here is Kansas State. Coach Bill Snyder has the Wildcats ranked No. 2 in the BCS standings this week. The 29 junior college players, the most among FBS-level programs, have certainly been a building block.

The state of Kansas also is a more lively juco football environment. Eight schools have football programs there compared to just three in Iowa.

“I’ve never said we wouldn’t look at a juco,” Ferentz said. Given the fact that there are fewer junior colleges in Iowa and “transitioning well” is cautionary, don’t expect a bounty.

Rules of Engagement
  • Be truthful. more
  • Be civil. more
  • Be responsible. more
  • Own your words. more
  • Leave the trolls alone. more
  • Take commercial ads elsewhere. more
  • Know that comments will be moderated. more
  • Or what? more
Three and Out . . .
  1. As we all know, Iowa is a developmental program, (and a slowly-developing one at that). It’s clear that KF’s methods aren’t conducive to the adjustments that would need to be made for JUCO transfers to be impactful on the field like that young gun coach in Manhattan’s are flexible for the betterment of the program. It’s best to continue on the same path of the past 8 years and develop our current and future players into a team that can win 7-8 games per year and a low-to-mid-level bowl.

    • K-State — bless it’s soul, it is one of my favorite football programs in the country, because it’s located at the ends of the earth — is a more friendly environment for jucos. READ: It’s easier for junior-college players to get into K-State than it is for them to get into Iowa. The number of jucos in Kansas dictates this. There are a lot of them.

      But Mike your point on Iowa not mining jucos for some sort of help . . . I don’t know what to make of that. Shortsighted? Not aggressive?

      Iowa got shot down by a few potential juco DEs last year or the year before. This year, they have an offer out to IWCC RB Aaron Wimberly, who’s committed to ISU.

      • I know about the admission requirements at Iowa vs. K-State; they are a significant factor in athletes looking at Iowa after working the JUCO ranks.

        However, Iowa has had some selective success with JUCO’s: Brad Banks and Marshall Yanda. When there’s huge attrition/injuries/etc. in consecutive recruiting classes, there absolutely should be much more aggression shown towards JUCO players to fill holes – especially in the skill positions (see: speed problem at WR; health in the backfield). I don’t portend to know all the details of why KF doesn’t adjust his philosophy on JUCO transfers or why not many seem to work out when he does bring them aboard. But when your best seasons out of the last eight only include ONE double-digit win total, all aspects of “we are who we are” should be reviewed. 8-win seasons would be failures in the classroom but can be tolerated on the field IF they’re sandwiched around more 10+ win seasons.

        As you said before: K-State is located at the “ends of the earth” and they not only pick up some excellent JUCO talent but 4-year talent as well. I know that KF’s way was successful the first half of his time here; I’d like to see him much more successful than he’s been for most of the second half of his time here – as would many other Hawkeye fans.

  2. I just read a great story on why teams should go for it on fourth and short. It also goes into why it’s mathematically prudent to occasionally go for two point conversions, fake punts/field goals, and onside kicks when the opposing team isn’t expecting it. Here it is if you’d like to read it, or forward it to Kirk.

    http://www.thepostgame.com/blog/men-action/201211/how-oregon-coach-chip-kelly-can-spark-moneyball-revolution-nfl

  3. How come no one ever talks about punting inside the opp. 40 yard line? I would bet my house up against $50 that no other team in Div 1 has half as my punts inside the 40 yard line than KF. It makes me want to puke when it happens. BTW I feel sick a lot watching Iowa play…..not just for those punts inside the 40 either

  4. I am a big KF fan. Even support his decision to leave JVB in the Penn State game. That’s another discussion. However, the 4th and inches was the WRONG call. At the least, a hard count. Iowa was in a position of losing the drivers seat to the Big 10 Championship (possible). The defense was tired, and more importantly, beaten. It was a foot or so, and 4 minutes to go.
    Great thing about KF; it’s over, move on.




Featured Jobs from corridorcareers.com