
Iowa linebacker Christian Kirksey and cornerback Greg Castillo collide during Iowa's 19-16 double-overtime win at Michigan State on Saturday. (Cliff Jette/The Gazette)
FIVE SENTENCES ON MICHIGAN STATE RESULT
1) Keenan Davis has had six catches in each of the last three games, and you better get used to hearing that because he, as much as anyone, is Iowa’s pass offense.
2) “The ankle is fine, it’ll be alright,” Iowa RB Mark Weisman said, “I don’t know if I could play on it right now, but I think it’ll be perfectly fine.”
3) Iowa TEs caught four passes for 20 yards and only had two other targets, with C.J. Fiedorowicz getting one catch and two other targets.
4) We will continue to turnover rocks and try to find the Rosette Stone that deciphers the Iowa passing game, and so the next stop is James Vandenberg’s mechanics.
5) The emotion thing with Ferentz . . . the look on his face when he tore off his headphones at the end . . . the catch in his voice when individuals are mentioned in the postgame . . . the man burns hot.
THREE PLAYERS WHO PLAYED
1) K Mike Meyer — Iowa radio analyst Ed Podolak said before Iowa’s third-and-9 play in the second OT that if the play went nowhere, the Hawkeyes would face a 42-yard field goal. The play was an incomplete pass intended for junior Jordan Cotton. Meyer uncorked a kick that looked as though it was aligned by a road survey crew. Straight down the pipe for the winning points. Meyer is now 14 of 15 this season, tying his career high with six games left this season. All of Iowa’s points Saturday were scored by walk-ons (or former walk-ons in Meyer’s case).
2) CB Greg Castillo — The first time he stepped on a scale at the University of Iowa, it told Castillo he weighed 155 pounds. After his interception to end it Saturday, the scale didn’t matter, four seasons as a reserve who skidded out in his shot as a starter didn’t matter. It was just a kid and a tipped pass, running toward his teammates with the ball held high in the air. It was Castillo’s second pick in as many weeks. Couple this with the punt he downed inside the 1 against Northern Illinois, that’s, arguably, two game-winning plays. Not a bad senior year.
3) WR Keenan Davis — The senior has caught six passes in the last three games. He’s on pace for his best season, which is saying something with Iowa still trying to find its way in the passing game. Davis is the go-to receiver and he’s taking advantage of everything that’s thrown his way.
TIGHTENING
1) Passing game — Perhaps, it’s this: Iowa’s passing game is shaky because it just doesn’t convert third-and-long plays. It doesn’t give itself a chance to make the routine. Vandenberg made one play Saturday — a flip pass to Kevonte Martin-Manley — where he extended the action and pulled something out of cleats. Last season, Vandenberg made “makeable” plays. This year, he isn’t and, thus, the chains don’t move or don’t move easily. Passing remains a question. In week 7, Vandenberg still has just two TD passes. Receivers have to get open. The playcalls have to give them a chance. The longer this goes, the more Vandenberg is left to answer for it. The presnap reads, the decision making, the blitz reads, none of it has jelled.
2) That underneath stuff — Iowa’s defense has done a much better job with its match-up zone, especially with the linebackers. Saturday, Michigan State found mismatches when it motioned LB Christian Kirksey to one side of the field. The Spartans also ran clear pick plays. One came on an important third-and-6 in the second half. LB James Morris fought through a pick, but the ball still found MSU receiver. An excellent open-field tackle by FS Tanner Miller saved the first down. This remains a hole in LB Anthony Hitchens’ game.
3) Greg Garmon — This isn’t a knock. He went into Saturday’s game stone cold in the overtimes after Mark Weisman couldn’t go with a leg/ankle injury. And he played like a true freshman who didn’t want to make the big mistake that cost his team. He might have to loosen up this week. It’s too early to call Weisman’s injury. Could be something, could be nothing.
TWO PLAYS
1) Outside zone left — It was the play that beat Northern Illinois and it was nearly the same situation. On third-and-long, OC Greg Davis called for an outside zone and RB Damon Bullock broke it 23 yards for the game-winning TD against Northern Illinois. Saturday, it was third-and-6 from MSU’s 45. Iowa was going four downs, and Davis called an outside zone. The Hawkeyes’ sealed off pursuit and Weisman was off for a good, first-down run. Then, guard Matt Tobin landed a late cut block on an MSU defender to help Weisman break it big. Thirty-seven yards later, it was first-and-goal at the 8.
2) Going through the window — I don’t know what the play was, but it was close to going nowhere. The Hawkeyes looked at second-and-26 from their 16. MSU DE Will Gholston got under Brett Van Sloten’s pads and started driving straight back into Vandenberg. Vandenberg launched the bomb to Davis, who had Darqueze Dennard beat by a step. The ball dropped into the chimney for a 35-yard gain and life for the Hawkeyes. Davis described it as a small window, but one they had to go through. Maybe this triggers something for Iowa’s struggling pass offense.
NEXT — PENN STATE (4-2, 2-0)
– The wonder story that is Penn State comes into Kinnick Stadium for a 7 p.m. Big Ten Network kickoff. After everything this program has gone through, the Nittany Lions are doing their school proud.
– Penn State QB Matt McGloin leads the Big Ten in passing with 249.8 yards a game. He has 12 TD passes to two interceptions. No, the Big Ten doesn’t have a comeback player of the year, but if it did, yes, McGloin would see a lot of votes.
BOX SCORE
SEASON STATS
CLOSER LOOK AT THE NUMBERS
Closing the deal (Red zone TDs/possessions)
Iowa 1-for-3
Michigan State 1-for-3
Field goals can win, too. The Spartans only got inside the Hawkeyes’ 30 three times.
Setting the tone (defensive three-and-outs)
Iowa 5 — Three of Iowa’s five came in the second half. Iowa’s D also held MSU to a FG after the Spartans reached Iowa’s 5 in the fourth quarter. Iowa’s defense was fantastic.
Michigan State 7 — That’s a winning number for the Spartans. Except they didn’t. Seriously, on the third-and-longs, Iowa passed short of the sticks because this game was all about ball security and field position. In the Iowa (Ferentz) against Michigan State (Dantonio) game, a punt is as good as a first down. Here have been the scores since Dantonio arrived in ’07 — 34-27 Iowa (2 OT), 16-13 MSU, 15-13 Iowa (Stanzi-McNutt on the last play), 37-6 Iowa, 37-21 Michigan State and now 19-16 Iowa (2 OT).
After adjustments (second-half yards and avg. yards per play)
Iowa 192-4.68
Michigan State 159-4.18
The Hawkeyes picked off 72 of those yards on two plays in the final drive. Behold, the power of clutch playmaking. It wasn’t SEC magical athleticism, it was the grunt of the grind. The Weisman 37-yard run was the Big Ten’s way of clutch. Eleven players doing what they needed to do. It’s not SportsCenter sexy, but it won at East Lansing. Iowa is a decidedly Big Ten football team.
Game-changers (offensive plays of 20-plus yards)
Iowa 3 — Weisman put up another two Saturday with runs of 31 and 37. He’s had five explosive runs in Iowa’s first two Big Ten games. He’s kind of a big deal to the Hawkeyes.
Michigan State 4 — WR Aaron Burbridge is only a freshman. He’s very fast and gets his head up. That allows him to see where to run and go where defenders aren’t.
Two-minute magic (points, final two minutes of half)
Iowa 7 — Weisman’s 5-yard TD came with 55 seconds left. It capped a nine-play, 68-yard drive that started with a first-and-24 and needed a 35-yard pass on a second-and-26 to keep it from bursting into flames. The power of the clutch play.
Michigan State 0 — The Spartans got the ball to Iowa’s 32 with six seconds left before halftime, but then they found themselves in a fire drill after everything already was on fire. An assistant coach ran out to the hash mark to pull a member of the field goal unit off the field. RB Le’Veon Bell ended up playing QB. Dantonio laughed it off with “You know what they say about best laid plans . . .” in a BTN interview before halftime. Dan Conroy could’ve handled a 49-yard field goal, but the Spartans could stop the clock and it might’ve cost them three points and, maybe, the game.
Marc;
You asked a question on throwing the ball short of the sticks alot with the split end video. I watched the game and then watched it again and counted the numbers up because I wonder why the Hawks throw short alot. Of the 37 pass attempts, 1 sack, 23 balls short of the sticks, 13 attempts pass the sticks. Now everyone is on JVB, however I feel that Coach Davis’s play calling or scheme is not very good and should caring the blame more than JVB.
With that said, a win is great and more importantly, “It’s Great to be a Hawkeye”
Your thoughts.
Thanks,
Hey Tom,
I think Iowa was set on safety all day last Saturday. With the wind and the rain and the uncertainty of Iowa’s passing game right now, punts were OK. Three-and-outs weren’t, but a punt isn’t viewed as a death sentence by this staff.
Last week, the defense allowed that to work. I’d say the better the defense is, the more conservative Iowa is. That’s just not true. The 2004 season was the opposite of that.
Marc, It is definitely mechanics. Vandy has awful mechanics for an actual football game where you can easily be blown off your spot. He might have good mechanics if football was like baseball and he was able to throw out of the wind-up, but that is not this game. First, he is wildly inaccurate. He struggles to hit guys on 10 yard passes. Guys were running routes, and there were windows, and they were 10 – 15 yards away, and to catch his passes they have to stop and contort. The reason is if he has to move his feet, at all, he losses his command and all he throws is a fastball.
I don’t know what you can do with a 5th year senior. The whole thing is in his head now. He’s become Chuck Knobloch. Maybe going under center might help, but I doubt it. But Iowa has to live with him. I do think the deep passes help him psychologically. I wish GD would call one early and let him overthrow one. Worst case on those is what happened yesterday: bad throw leads to interference, good throw leads to great catch.
(con’t) Vandy uses more leg drive on passes than any player in the conference and certainly more than any NFL player you will find. Because of that his footwork has to be awesome and yesterday he was bailing out on every pass, waiting for the rush to consume him. He has to drive into the pass. Without that he’s basically useless. The reason he is so streaky is because of this aspect of his mechanics. He’s manageable when he’s allowed to set and drive. He’s a wreck when he cannot. I don’t know if he just has a weak arm or was trained to throw this way, but it is a very limiting technique. It is literally how Roger Clemens throws a fastball.
Well written-post, Pete.
I’d add that I think he’s a little late on some throws because he instinctively pulls it down if he doesn’t have confidence getting the ball there. Also, I believe almost all Iowa QBs are programmed to err on the side of caution.
To blame Davis’s offense for Vanderberg’s ineffectiveness is not fair. There was several perfect calls by Davis. The first pick by Vandenberg which set up Mich. St first TD was on a perfectly called screen pass which caught Mich. ST. in a blitz and would have probable been a TD for Iowa. Later another called screen had three blockers in front of Wiesman and the ball was thrown over his head. Still later a wide open Weisman ran up the gut and Vandy threw behind him and high. Great opportunities all missed. That last one led to the Mich St. field goal. That’s 10 points I’m hanging on Vanderberg and 3 on the defense. I felt Iowa could have scored at least 21 points (seven more if a certain tight end had been suspended instead of bravely pushing a kicker in the back). I do not believe that Vandy can make the throws needed in Davis’s offense. The quick outs to the WRs has to be a throw that is mostly arm strength. Can Ruddick make that throw? I guess we’ll find out next year. Because somehow I’m to believe that he could play worse than Vandenberg. Is he going to somehow shoot himself or fall in a well? Seriously I’ll watch a struggling rookie over a struggling senior.
Again, doesn’t trust the arm to make the throw. Doesn’t see it and compute it quickly enough. That could be. Good point.
Great level-headed posts. Appreciate it.
Thanks for the stats breakdown, Tom!