IOWA CITY — The slogan for Iowa’s football team as the 2012 season approached was “Enter the Black.”
Mission accomplished. The Hawkeyes tumbled into the heart of darkness Saturday at Kinnick Stadium.

Central Michigan celebrates what would be a game-winning field goal (Jim Slosiarek/The Gazette-KCRG)
Some freaky-bad deja vu: Iowa had a running back rush for over 200 yards and still lost to an unremarkable, double-digit underdog by one point instead of kicking that dog.
That happened to to the Hawkeyes last October in their 22-21 defeat at Minnesota late last October. Marcus Coker carried 32 times for 252 yards and two touchdowns for Iowa. It didn’t matter.
On Saturday at Kinnick Stadium, it was Central Michigan 32, Iowa 31. Iowa’s Mark Weisman, who has quickly become college football’s foremost authority on how to stiff-arm and disarm opposing defenders, had 27 rushes for 217 yards and three scores.
It’s almost incredible this column isn’t a sequel to last week’s feel-good Weisman story. It should have been, because teams with 200-yard rushers don’t lose. Or rather, they shouldn’t.
A team with a 200-yard rusher has usually imposed its will on its opponent. It typically means it played the game the way it wanted, and didn’t let the opposition dictate any terms.
But this is Iowa football in the 2010s, when the door is often left open for foes believed to be inferior. You find ways to lose two straight years to Minnesota teams that were not good. You run the ball down the throat of a Central Michigan club that had been 4-19 against FBS competition since the start of the 2010 season.
You still lose.
Iowa’s offense racked up 430 yards and was dominant on its final possession of Saturday’s game, driving for a touchdown with 2:18 left and a 31-23 lead.
Then the Hawkeye defense wilted and gave up a TD drive to make it 31-29 with: 45 remaining. But the Chippewas’ 2-point conversion try failed. That was a big whew.
Then Iowa had had what seemed like a day-and-a-half to figure out how what CMU was up to as it prepared its onside kick, but the Hawkeyes froze when it counted. Just like it did at Minnesota last October.
“We looked very confused out there, and that’s not a good thing,” Iowa Coach Kirk Ferentz said about the fateful kick. “We were indecisive.”
Then the defense shriveled again as CMU senior quarterback Ryan Radcliff masterfully gained the necessary yardage for David Harman to get his shot at the 47-yard field goal that he made.
Enter the Black? A black hole, maybe.
This wasn’t Iowa’s opening game, where you can say you had kinks to work out, a la the 18-17 win over Northern Illinois. This was Week 4, the lead-in to the Big Ten season. This was supposed to be the Hawkeyes moving forward, building some confidence and credibility.
But this was a team that didn’t make anything good happen on special teams unless it came directly off the foot of place-kicker Mike Meyer or punter John Wienke.
This was a team that often had trouble getting the right players on the field on defense, let alone getting them in the right spots. This was a team making foolish penalty after foolish enalty. Four personal fouls?!?
“Undisciplined” seemed like an apt description of the Hawkeyes.
“I think anything that has nine penalties, seven of them being majors, that word would probably fit right in there,” Ferentz said. “So I would have to say so. Undisciplined, sloppy, however you want to look at it.”
And don’t forget, Central Michigan settled for field goals on three different trips inside the Iowa 12-yard line.
In perhaps the cruelest irony of all, the Hawkeyes would probably have won this game had they gone into a fetal position on their final possession of the first half.
For all the times fans wanted Kirk Ferentz’s teams to take a couple shots downfield in the last two minutes of the half and barked when he wouldn’t, on Saturday Iowa did just that. Sort of. They weren’t what you would call great shots.
A holding penalty, two incompletions, a 7-yard pass immediately followed by a CMU timeout, and the visitors got the ball back via 30-yard punt with 1:19 and two timeouts left.
The Iowa drive took a mere 41 seconds and left. Radcliff subsequently guided his team to the Iowa 3 before the Chippewas settled for a field goal and probably grumbled about it. Little did they know it’s eventual worth.
The Hawkeyes aren’t good, folks. They weren’t good last season, and they aren’t good now.
You knew this year would probably be bumpy, but you expect a team to make tangible progress from week to week.
Sure, Iowa’s offense hammered on ordinary Mid-American Conference defense. But when the Hawkeyes leave an unspectacular nonconference schedule with a 2-2 record and are riddled by Central Michigan’s offense, this season has the potential to be tedious.
“Obviously you’d love to be 4-0,” said Iowa quarterback James Vandenberg, “but that’s not the case. We haven’t played well enough to be 4-0.
“When you go through these tough situations you really see peoples’ inner character. I have a lot of faith in the guys in the locker room, offense, defense, special teams. We’ll respond to this.”
Maybe they will. But they sure didn’t respond on Saturday in many ways, and this game counted, too.
“I tell our team all the time we get what we deserve,” Ferentz said, “and that’s what we got today.”
Again.
To employ Kirk’s mantra for fans: We do NOT deserve the mediocrity on the field that’s been in place for much of the past 8 years (save 2009). One for the last eight isn’t exactly “earning his money” in ANY coaching job ANYWHERE. For those that love the “NFL development” fact: even developmental programs need to challenge for the conference crown AT LEAST once every 3-4 years (saw that somewhere else, but makes sense).
Of course, as I’ve posted elsewhere: until oldtimers and others quit writing checks to the I-Club and tickets to bowl games, there will be exactly no reason whatsoever for KF to change a thing. Expecting Barta to actually govern the athletic program is a waste of time. Besides, even if he tries, some folks will call on the ghosts of Ray Nagel, Bob Cummings and even Steve Alford to fight any major changes to the program.
It is obvious to me that KF and staff did not prepare these guys at all and have little ability to do in-game management, and have been deficient that way for years. Do you remember our greatest victory ever, the Capital One Bowl in 2005? It was won when we mismanaged the clock and Drew Tate threw a desperation heave to Holloway. We never should have won that one, and is typical of how the coaching staff “manages” a game.
It is obvious to me that Ferentz peaked years go. He collects the sixth-highest coaching salary in the nation, and all five of the coaches who are paid more have won national titles in the past ten years (Miles, Stoops, Saban, Brown and Meyer). We have never gotten close, and under Ferentz’s leadership, we never will. Two BCS bowls in 14 years. A clutch of lesser bowls. It seems that Ferentz is a coach that can get you to “respectable”, but cannot push through to elite status, rather like Jim Mora in the NFL. How long will we pay top dollar for the kind of disgraceful effort we saw today? Is $4 million a year appropriate for a seemingly endless series of 7-5 or 6-6 seasons? We must look like gullible hicks to the rest of the football world. And I guess we are.
Inside the denial bubble that surrounds Iowa City, no one seems to see the cold numbers, and this disgraceful performance will again be rewarded with loyalty and a lot of excuses. Out here where the rest of us live, we see it a little clearer. Kirk Ferentz, as nice a guy as he is, has had his shot. It is time for a new direction.
Well-said, Mike, well-said. Iowa shouldn’t be mediocre and rebuilding, not after some of the seasons they’ve had in the past. At least we can watch good college football on television this fall. Unfortunately it’s not Iowa football. It’s Oregon, and Alabama.
As your boy Neil Young would preach,
“Out of the blue
and into the black
They give you this,
but you pay for that
And once you’re gone,
you can never come back
When you’re out of the blue
and into the black.”
The black has been entered, and the great unwashed masses have had their eyes opened. They don’t like what they see. $21 million,…. you pay for that, as Niel roared!
Unheeded prophesies were ignored(I tried to open the eyes, but would be ridiculed). Look to the west, and a little north. The side of light and good also has a bandwagon, but it is VERY full now.
Applications are being taken.
The program seems to have lost something. I said in another story comment section that the team seemed to regress quite a bit this week. It just feels different this year than, say 2007, the last time Iowa had mediocre/young/inexperienced talent.
If they somehow manage to beat Minnesota next week than MAYBE they can salvage something but this team looks lost. How a college football team can lose 2 games in a year when a RB runs for over 200 yards is beyond me. That’s almost IMPOSSIBLE. Seriously. I have no idea how that happens.
Kind of a nice little symbol for where the program is at.
Where to start, 6 fouls called on Iowa in the first half 0 on C. Michigan. I saw players on both sides pushing after the play and sucker hits all day long. Normally a ref calls both sides equally in these situations or nothing. Iowa players on D were shoving players into position as the plays was snapped, often with players out of position. Coaching indecision costing Iowa momentum and time outs. Two free previews of the onside kick which cost them the game with no coaching changes from the sidelines. No holding or pass interference calls on CM at almost any point, fouls which everyone else in the stadium saw. (No, fans were not booing the players, they were booing the refs.) A 5th year QB that still can’t read “hot routes” that should have been TD’s and were lucky not to be pick sixes. A defense that played cushion all day but tried for a pick at the worst possible time. (If your going to shoot a route you better make the play). A defense that again howled in the second half after meowing in the first half. I agree that right now Iowa is a bad team. But they are so close to being a good team. Kirk Ferentz’s coaching used to be the difference between the two. I don’t know what’s going on in Iowa City but this team AND COACHING STAFF needs to get on the same page or a 2-3 win season is VERY possible. To not be all negative, the offensive line was “sick”. They were the players of the game. Truckers from I-80 were confusing the holes they were paving as off-ramps. This game will stick with me for a long time because this was a senseless loss.
Guys, stop complaining. We are only into our 14th year of rebuilding, hang in there, we will be able to start requecting kids from the glory year playes, LOL……Does Chuck Long have a son?
Oops, I just figured it out, They have these new uniforms every week and they are not suppose to get then dirty, Maybe they cant return or sell them if they have foot prints on the back side, just a thought
This summer, My wife and I made the decision to move to Florida(Tampa area)…my thought process was , well I can finally just drive to a Iowa bowl game, Well there goes that Idea, well there is always Busch Gardens
as is said by many CUBS fans… “well. there is always next year”
For fans of Iowa Athletics, this fall may just be an Indiana (IU) type of fall.
They type of fall that screams ” When does basketball season start”
Iowa was obviously very poorly prepared but this game and deserved to lose based on how they played BUT I also give the officiating crew an “F”. Looking at just that last few minutes of the game:
- On the last drive for CM’s touchdown they called Gagglione for a personal foul but didn’t call the CM played for holding when he obviously rolled over on Gaglione.
- On the same series the CM QB was obviouly over the line on the pass play that was reviewed.
- On the enusing kickoff CM was called for delay of game BUT was not penalized – no yardage was marked off. I don’t have the play clock but its hard to imagine that there weren’t actually two of delay of game infractions.
Earlier in the game Iowa got called for pushing and shoving where the CM players were obviously trash talking and shoving as well.
The quality of Iowa’s play was just terrible. I can’t give CM much credit as they succeeded in large part because Iowa faile to execute in so many situations you just can’t count them.
I totally agree with you Paul
don’t blame the Refs, CM is a MAC team that a decent IOWA team would have beaten by 30 points. KF and staff did a piss poor job of preparing the team. And we have to make a change at QB or we won’t win another game.