Managing editor of The Gazette and TheGazette.com.
Updated: 5 September 2012 | 10:18 am in Inside The Newsroom, Local News

REPOSTING: TheGazette.com commenting has changed

Commenting welcomed on Daily Conversations, Reporter Notebooks


thegazette.com Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Editor’s note: We blogged Sunday about changes to TheGazette.com and The Gazette that launched this week, but there’s been some confusion around the online commenting piece. So we’re reposting that part of the explainer for those who may have missed it.

Previously posted: Also on Tuesday, Sept. 4, 2012, we’ll launch major changes to online commenting at TheGazette.com. The new Daily Conversations section will feature three fresh conversations a day on topics of local interest that we believe people are or will want to talk about. Conversations will remain active for 72 hours, and then commenting will be closed. By the end of the week, we’ll have nine daily conversations at a time to choose from.

We’ll provide a little background and links to information on each topic to help users familiarize themselves with the conversation so they can offer insightful commentary. All comments will be moderated, meaning no comments appear until a moderator approves them. Moderation will be staffed from 7:30 a.m. to 7 p.m., so you’ll likely see a batch of comments post each morning from the overnight hours.

All comments are subject to The Gazette’s rules of engagement, which are not changing. They are, in brief:

  • Be truthful. Cite your sources. Comments should be on topic, accurate, timely and fair. Share your eyewitness accounts, background, observations and history. Ask about what you don’t know.
  • Be civil. Do not monopolize the conversation. Do not make personal attacks on others. Do not use ALLCAPs; no need to shout. The same goes for imperatives, such as “Wake up, people,” or examples of Godwin’s Law (Nazi comparisons).
  • Be responsible. Refrain from using obscene, vulgar, lewd or sexually oriented language; statements that convey racism, sexism or terminology that degrades another person or class of people; and attacks on others that range from being against someone’s character to threatening someone’s physical safety.
  • Own your words. Use your real name.
  • Leave the trolls alone. Don’t be a troll, either; they are not welcome at TheGazette.com.

You don’t have to agree with these rules, but to comment in our digital spaces, you’ll have to follow them. Comments that don’t will not be approved for posting. Because of the volume of comments we get each day, you may not be notified when and why a comment is rejected.

We invite you to explore our new Reporter Notebooks feature at TheGazette.com as well. Each of our topical content areas — business, government, public safety, education, sports and living — have this feature. It’s where the reporters blog about what they’re doing, reading, learning or talking about each workday. The goal is transparency around the reporting process. It’s not where you’ll find our completed stories but where you can see the bits and pieces of what reporters are working on. You’ll also find reporters’ Twitter streams on the notebooks.

Reporters will take comments on the notebooks as well. Rules of engagement apply. So if you’ve ever wanted to offer your expertise to a reporter, offer a news tip or ask a reporter a question, the notebook is the place. It’s a chance to have an impact on the reporting we do every day.

There will no longer be comments on completed articles, but again, you have the Daily Conversations and the Reporter Notebooks as options for engaging with us.

Enhanced by Zemanta
Rules of Engagement
  • Be truthful. more
  • Be civil. more
  • Be responsible. more
  • Own your words. more
  • Leave the trolls alone. more
  • Take commercial ads elsewhere. more
  • Know that comments will be moderated. more
  • Or what? more
REPOSTING: TheGazette.com commenting has changed
  1. So, looking at the rules, I can’t use the “I” word when referring to a person or group of people. I guess I will have to use the phrase “mentally challenged” from now on.

  2. It’s your site and newspaper, so you set the rules.

    It’s my time, so there’s not much reason to check in with The Gazette anymore.

    • Thanks for the explanation. Silly me I thought maybe you had censored all the comments. That explains why I felt like returning to a ghost town. I’m with Jon on this one.
      So your actually trying to have the most boring newspaper? Good luck with that.

  3. Looks like libs won’t be able to post in the Gazzette anymore…
    I see the Gazzette is owned by the same company that ownes the Casper star tribune…they have a policy that you don’t have to use your real name…they also have a policy that shows recent coments and at what time…like William ofoakham said…it’s to protect the integrety of his mailbox….I really don’t see the importance to post under your real name in the Gazzett when any other paper in the united states does not require it…BUT…it is YOUR paper….your rules…

  4. It is plain you made changes, the reason why is missing.

    Like Jon, my page hits decrease. Its your game.

  5. Nice way to keep most community input at a new low. I guess Mr. Corbett will be happy about the discourse in the community now!

    • It will be less embarrassing for the gazette, they can pick and choose which news can be posted on and now they can post the talking points from the city officals and no one can point out that is what they are, instead of the gazette doing some real reporting of the news.

  6. The mayor has gotten done what he complained about months ago; silencing his critics. Hence forth the Gazette will only allow you only to comment on feel good stories of their choosing; new bike paths on 3rd Ave, the water plant winning a major award, etc. Just like city council making commenting at their meetings next to impossible for the average taxpayer the Gazette has chosen to follow suit.

    Here’s one more hit to the Gazette’s financial coffers; please cancel my 7 day a week subscription (for the last 13 years) to your newspaer effective immediately (you may donate any remaining subscription to your charity). If you won’t allow me to comment on all stories (sans sensitive crime stories) I won’t allow your paper in my home any longer. Censorship at its best. Shame on you Gazette!

    • Yep—I’m doing the same.—and for the same reasons. I tried to say that earlier, but The Censors didn’t like my naming the owners…

  7. I cannot see how these changes will dramatically cut comments. I appreciate the opportunity to be a part of the Gazette comment community. People are starting to take the internet for granted. As I post this, all 9 previous comments are negative–complaining about a free service provided by a for-profit business . . .

  8. Wow this is definately gonna change my viewing habits of this website. I found the old systems was a way people could express their opinions and debate the issues and events of Cedar Rapid and the world. This new system is censorship and I will be finding another source to occupy my time. What a shame there were some good people on here who provided much insight into topics and I enjoyed reading them. Even though I didnt always agree with them it was nice to see others perspective on the issues. Thumbs down to the gazette for the change.




Featured Jobs from corridorcareers.com