Mike Hlas

Hi, I'm Gazette/TheGazette.com sports columnist Mike Hlas. This is the Hlog. We will meet here, discuss things, and then go [...]
Updated: 2 September 2012 | 2:28 pm in Sports, The Hlog by Mike Hlas, Uncategorized

Hlas column: Iowa and ISU won on points Saturday, while UNI won on style


thegazette.com Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

How would you rank the football programs of Iowa’s three state universities based solely on Saturday’s opening-game performances alone?

You could have a spirited debate over No. 1. Is it Northern Iowa for pushing Wisconsin way harder than the Badgers or anyone else dreamed they would be pushed before falling, 26-21 in Madison? Or is it Iowa State, which posted a 38-23 win over a Tulsa team that was 44-22 over the previous five seasons and has put a lot of scoreboard lights to work with its offense?

It certainly wouldn’t be Iowa. Although, ’tis far better to win than not, and the Hawkeyes did just that against a salty Northern Illinois club, 18-17.

Northern Iowa's Brett LeMaster leaps for a catch vs. Wisconsin (AP photo)

I might lean to the only team of the three that didn’t win, though. Had Las Vegas posted a line on the UNI-Wisconsin game, the Badgers probably would have been a 35- to 40-point pick.

Wisconsin’s average margin of victory against its four nonconference foes last year was 40 points. That included a 49-7 stomping of Northern Illinois in Chicago, and the Huskies went on to go 11-3.

Had you told me Montee Ball would score just one touchdown for Wisconsin, I would have thought you were guessing he would get injured midway through the first quarter. Had you predicted Ball would be held under four yards per carry (32 rushes for 120 yards) I would have assumed you thought Ball’s five 1-yard touchdown runs would lower his yards-per-carry average.”

Here’s what Ball said: “Very frustrated. I guess because I am kind of used to the big holes and the 40-yard runs.”

UNI gave a wonderful account of itself. It never surrendered, even when it was down 19-0 in the third quarter and had yet to move the ball into Wisconsin territory.

The Panthers were using a red-shirt freshman at quarterback, an Oklahoman with a great name. Sawyer Kollmorgan kept battling. He hit on two long touchdown passes and threw for 268 yards.

“There’s a lot of FBS schools that I’d rather play than those guys,” Wisconsin coach Bret Bielema said. “They’re a really, really good football team.

“I told (Badger players) that any win is a good win. It couldn’t have been any better.”

Scoff if you will, but that was the same feeling Iowa’s players and coaches seemed to have Saturday night in Chicago. They, like Wisconsin, knew coming in that they weren’t going up against blocking dummies.

If you want to go broke, a good way is to underestimate non-BCS outfits with proven track records, like Northern Iowa and Northern Illinois. Football teams can be pretty good even if they don’t have a “B1G” stamped on their jerseys.

Another such club is Tulsa. The Golden Hurricane rarely gets noticed in its own state, let alone nationally. But part of the reason Marvin McNutt of Iowa is on the Philadelphia Eagles’ practice squad and not its active roster is because undrafted free agent Damaris Johnson of Tulsa came in and won a receiver’s job with the Eagles.

Tulsa jumped to a 16-7 first-quarter lead in Ames Saturday. Many an ISU team of the past would have folded. These Cyclones bore down, and led 24-16 at halftime, and outplayed the Hurricane after that.

That is a very good win. Iowa State was a Vegas underdog. This was the eighth time ISU has won as the underdog in Paul Rhoads’ three seasons + one game.

Iowa State's Steele Jantz eludes a Hurricane (AP photo)

Now, the Cyclones still have quite a distance to travel to even be in the discussion as a program that can finish in the top half of the Big 12, which may be the nation’s foremost football conference this year even though Alabama resides in the SEC. But the talent keeps getting better in Ames, and so does the depth.

Shontrelle Johnson darted off the sideline and reclaimed his No. 1 spot at running back with 120 yards on 18 carries. James White was no slouch himself Saturday, with 10 totes for 54 yards.

Steele Jantz had as good of an opening game at quarterback as the Cyclones could have expected with a career-high 281 passing yards. ISU has a better and much more balanced offense than does Northern Illinois, so Iowa’s defense has some work to do this week.

Rhoads will say the exact same thing about his team, and he’ll be right. His ISU teams have yet to build a week-to-week consistency that mark a strong program. He needs a second-straight strong showing by his men to have a decent chance of taking home the latest version of the Cy-Hawk Trophy.

In 2009, Iowa beat UNI by just one point, then beat Iowa State the following Saturday. In 2011, ISU beat the Panthers by just one point, then turned around the next week and defeated Iowa.

Week 1 always changes a lot of impressions about college football teams. Week 2 usually does, also.

 

 

 

 

Rules of Engagement
  • Be truthful. more
  • Be civil. more
  • Be responsible. more
  • Own your words. more
  • Leave the trolls alone. more
  • Take commercial ads elsewhere. more
  • Know that comments will be moderated. more
  • Or what? more
Hlas column: Iowa and ISU won on points Saturday, while UNI won on style
  1. Moral “victories” now outweigh actual victories?

    Did the Panthers players also get participation ribbons?

    Maybe, underestimating opponents, in Madison, is the problem. Just ask Bo.

  2. Great points, Mike. And I was thinking the same thing. Anyone who is halfway objective would have to have all the respect in the world for UNI. Some people don’t seem to understand that UNI is, by NCAA designation, a rung lower than the Iowas and Wisconsins and Alabamas of the world. UNI has a minuscule budget in comparison, and far fewer scholarships, and so on. So anyone who doesn’t get that UNI losing by five and driving for the winning score at the end is a bigger accomplishment, by far, than what either Iowa or ISU did last Saturday isn’t paying attention.

    I’m an Iowa grad and long-time Hawkeye fan and have even dabbled in playing and coaching here and there, and I find it fantastic that the UNIs and the William & Marys and the San Jose States can now do what they did this past weekend.

    I don’t think there’s any way you can give too much credit to UNI. If Iowa and ISU came as close to getting their money’s worth as UNI consistently does every Saturday, they’d be playing for national titles — which, BTW, is what UNI does in its own division almost every year.

    Sure, winning is winning. But at least in college football, winning is NOT everything.

  3. I dunno Mike. From these results, It seems to me that B10 teams (and their sportswriters) have a history of underestimating opponents from ‘lesser conferences’. Unlike the Badgers and the Hawkeyes, the Cyclones at least did not underestimate their opponent. Furthermore, if you remove the final seven minutes of the first quarter, and the 77 yard dash by Tulsa’s Trey Watts in waning minutes of the fourth quarter, ISU really didn’t have too many problems with Tulsa.

    • If you take away the 23 points they scored ISU wins 31-0.
      THe first seven minutes of the 1st quarter and 77 yard rushes in the 4th quarter of an 8 point game still count right?
      Neither team has any reason to be cocky this week.

    • I’d love to know why you think that Iowa underestimated its opponent while ISU didn’t? Because they won by less? That’s a horrible unit of measure of estimating something.

  4. I don’t and haven’t underestimated the upper crust of FCS programs, and that especially includes Northern Iowa. I’ve seen the Panthers beat ISU and scare the you-know-what out of Iowa over the years.

    I covered Appalachian State’s win n the then I-AA national-title game two years before it shocked Michigan, so I already knew the caliber of player App State had before it got that unforgettable win. To me, it was a big upset, but it wasn’t like Michigan was playing a really poor team from the Mid-American Conference or Sun Belt. Appalachian State would have beaten a lot of FBS teams at that time.

    But that upper crust I referred to isn’t a large group. It sure doesn’t include Savannah State, which Oklahoma State beat 84-0, and which now plays at Florida State.

    Those games are farces.

  5. Jay, this was anything but a moral victory for UNI. They get a great payday out of it, and prepare for their conference schedule against top competition. It is much like having your high school baseball team hitters practice against a Triple-A or major league pitcher. When they face someone on their own level of competition, they dominate. Look at the FCS success of the Panters for proof. Shoot, watch the movie “The Rookie” if you don’t believe me!

  6. I just watched the last half of UNI-Wisconsin. Wow. UNI was even better than I imagined. They owned the Badgers in the second half, rolling up about 250 yards of offense, scoring 21 points, and committing TWO penalties the entire game in front of those 80,000 rabid Wisconsin maniacs.

    Like I said before, there’s no way you can so enough about UNI, a perennial national title contender at its own level. With a freshman QB in his first start and a D-line about half the size of the mountains that masquerade as a Wisconsin O-line, UNI came up short on a 4th and 1 as it was driving in Badger territory for the winning TD.

    Iowa couldn’t get a pass downfield against NIU, but UNI baffled the Badgers with its vertical attack the entire second half while doing a great job of protecting its QB. Bielema wasn’t kidding when he said he was glad to get out with the win. UNI looked like a well-oiled machine at Camp Randall while Iowa, with its 5th year senior QB, looked like a suburban JV team that had taken the wrong turn and ended up at Solider Field.

    Maybe Iowa should spend some time reviewing that UNI tape to see what a football team and a vertical passing game look like. They could learn some things that might come in handy for the next several Saturdays.




Featured Jobs from corridorcareers.com