Who would you say is the best NFL player among all the ex-Iowa Hawkeyes currently in the league?
When I thought about this, the answer that leaped to my mind was Minnesota Vikings linebacker Chad Greenway. He hasn’t missed a game in the last five seasons, and averaged 9.6 tackles per game last season. Greenway is a terrific pro player.
The NFL Network is counting down its top 100 NFL players, 10 per week. It has given us Nos. 61 through 100. So far, no ex-Hawkeyes.
Pete Prisco of CBSsports.com gave his top 100 all in one burst. There is just one former Iowa player. He is No. 44 Marshal Yanda, Baltimore Ravens guard.
Offensive linemen never get enough respect. I should have thought of Yanda immediately. The guy was a Pro Bowler last year. He’s good.
Prisco wrote: This right guard has emerged as one of the league’s best. He is a tough-guy mauler who can also block well in protection.
I’ll cede to that.
So who are the top five former Hawkeyes in the NFL. My criteria would be like Prisco’s and the NFL Network’s. It isn’t based on a body of work, but the here and now. So, tight end Dallas Clark would have been atop or near the top of this list the last several years, but not now. The same goes for defensive end Aaron Kampman.
I’ll go with (in this order) Yanda, Greenway, New York Jets running back Shonn Greene (1,054 rushing yards last year), Indianapolis linebacker Pat Angerer (148 tackles last year), and … and … and then it gets difficult.
Defensive tackle Karl Klug had seven sacks in his rookie season for the Tennessee Titans. Defensive end Adrian Clayborn of Tampa Bay forced a pair of fumbles in December, and seems a safe bet to crack the top five soon and stay there a while. Nate Kaeding has been a Pro Bowl performer kicking for San Diego, but missed all but one game last season because of injury.
I’ll go with Green Bay Packers offensive tackle Bryan Bulaga at fifth.
Do I have a glaring omission? Who would be in your top five?
I would go with Spievey, 70 tkls, 1 sack 3 int.
Mike…
I can’t believe you’re forgetting Casey Wiegmann–175 consecutive starts at center in the NFL…
To have that kind of ironman ability in the NFL is nothing short of amazing…
I think he was reportedly retiring this offseason, so he wouldn’t be eligible for the “here and now” discussion.
He hasn’t made a decision yet, Rupert… The Chiefs are giving him time…but they have drafted some younger talent coming in.
However, it still doesn’t change the fact that 175 straight starts in the NFL is huge achievement..especially for someone at that position.
What happened to your mention of Tony Mo? And why was my post changed? Why did the article change? You had Tony as number 5 now you have Bulaga? If you are basing your selections on who played and didn’t miss time (your original article) then you have to have Spievey.
I edited it because I had incorrectly listed Moeaki’s stats from last year. Bulaga missed four games, but he was otherwise a pillar for the team with the NFL’s best regular-season record. Your case for Spievey is certainly legit. I posted this for everyone to make their own cases.
I think when you start talking about greatest ever this or that, you’re doing a great disservice to any player who falls out of criteria of here and now. There are several Iowa player who should be mentioned on this list, but because they didn’t play for Ferentz or Fry, they are left off the list? What about the Hilgenbergs, Podolaks or Karras’s of earlier eras. Don’t they deserve mention? Until recently, Ed Podolak had the greatest game ever by any player from any school while paying for the Kansas City Chiefs he also held the team rushing record until the Nigerian Nightmare came along. Wally Hilgenberg played on 4 Super Bowl teams. Alex Karras was a perennial All Pro. Don’t these guys deserve mention?