It really was. The writing, reporting, editing and presentation were terrific, and the content was plentiful and had depth. It was one of the best newspapers in America, and has the Pulitzer Prizes to support that claim.
One of the reporters who won a Pulitzer at the paper (for public service), Jane Schorer Meisner, was laid off (fired) Tuesday. So were 12 other newsroom employees, including one of the best photographers around, John Gaps III, sportswriter Dan Johnson, and sports columnist Sean Keeler.
This isn’t the Register’s first go-round with downsizing in the last few years. As part of the Gannett chain, layoffs, pay-cuts, furloughs, etc., have been standard operating procedure there in recent times. There have been four such rounds of layoffs since 2008. The company lopped off 700 jobs this week.
Chopping staff has happened at virtually every newspaper, of course. My company got out the blade in 2009. Three members of the Gazette’s nine-person sportswriting staff were shoved out the door in one swift purge. I have good friends elsewhere in the country who made newspapering a career and were very good at it. They were laid off.
It’s a surely become a tired story to you to hear about the problems companies that own newspapers are having trying to enter a new-media world. Mine is trying. It’s hard, and it requires a lot of changing of mindsets about many things. It’s often frustrating, and it means walking through some dark tunnels in order to reach the light, but I like our chances a lot better than Gannett’s.
Of course, I’m just a voice on the sideline, not some genius like those Gannett top executives. Its CEO, Craig Dubow, had his salary doubled last year, to $9.4 million. Its chief operating officer, Gracia Matore, made $8.2 million. She also doubled her salary from 2009.
So somebody at the company is making out all right.
Gannett’s way isn’t everybody’s way, as this column from the Poynter Institute’s Rick Edmonds tells us. Edmonds wrote:
Metro papers like the Boston Globe and Dallas Morning News that have adopted a high price/high quality circulation strategy know readers will not be satisfied with skinny papers that have little worth reading. So those newsrooms are protected and, in a few cases, growing.
Other individual papers or chains, especially those that are debt-free, like Scripps or A.C. Belo, are willing to operate at break even or at a modest loss for now to keep the news core strong and invest in a range of digital startups.
Everything shakes itself out in business over time. Those who innovate with eyes on the future survive. Those who don’t go bye-bye.

Sean Keeler
Keeler is a supremely talented writer who proved that time after time in his work for the Register. It sure looked like he embraced the changes to our business as much as anyone at his paper. He blogged on the Register’s website, held live chats with readers every week, hosted webcasts, reached out to readers via social media, and continued to write essays and features that required a lot of thought and commitment and skill. He added genuine value to his company.
A lot of companies still reciprocate when that happens. Gannett clearly isn’t among them, unless the value an employee brings comes from reducing the rest of the work force.
Anyone else remember “The Big Peach”? What a shame that the Register is now a shell of its former self. Marc Hansen and Randy Peterson had an avid reader back then. Times have changed though from when you had to fight to be the first to get to see the sports page in my house on Sunday morning.
Ah’, the Big Peach. I had forgotten until Capt A reminded me.
Sometimes the mighty trip and sometimes they fall. The Register has fallen to the point of being unrecognizable.
My brother once owned a Chevy Malibu, early 1970′s edition. That thing was mean and nasty and awesome. Chevy still makes a Malibu, but except for the name, you wouldn’t recognize it.
Change isn’t always good. Example A – Chevy Malibu. Example B – DSM Register.
I used to have the Register mailed to me back in the “Big Peach” days. No more. For what it’s worth, Gannett has also made a mess of the Arizona Republic, where they also got layoff notices yesterday.
When Walter Cronkite retired, we found out he was a liberal. Before that, we had no clue where he fell on the political spectrum, because he was a professional, and a man of integrity. That is missing today, and I believe it is a contributing factor to the decline of the newspaper, perhaps as much as the internet. Unfortunately, the sports page is forced to go along for the ride.
Gannett should know it can’t keep cutting content providers and expect people to continue paying for that content. I’m glad you pointed out the media companies that are investing in reporting and not just executive multimillion dollar salaries.
Mike, if news organizations all become parts of “media profit centers,” who is going to do the public-service work of investigative reporting? I shudder at the prospect of for-profit reporting, and we are seeing the implications right now: shallow celebrity-focused news, with dash of “it if bleeds, it leads.”
Edward R. Murrow was an early victim of the bottom line for his expose of Joseph McCarthy. The man must be twirling in his grave contemplating the current state of American corporate “journalism.”
Even though I haven’t regularly read the Des Moines Register since my college days (back when hard copies of newspapers were still found in college libraries), this piece and its implications for the whole of print journalism sickens me.
I remember the Register when I was growing up in CR. It was a fascinating paper to read, but many folks thought it should be printed on pink paper because of it’s stand on many things. I do miss both it and the Gazette, though. Where I now live there is only one ‘local’ paper and so we buy NYC papers to get a broader view of what’s going on in the world.
I think it was President Jimmy Carter who once said he made a point of trying to read four newspapers every morning – the New York Times, the Washington Post, the L.A. Times and the Register – just to try to keep his finger on the pulse of the nation. I, too, grew up with the Big Peach and the Register’s demise is, indeed, sad. I apologize to all my old co-workers, but so too is the Gazette’s. Iowa use to have some outstanding newspapers.
Keep plugging away, brother.
Remember the sequential photos of an Iowa touchdown, shot from the press box, with players identified in little boxes next to their images on the field? Larry Lawrence to Ed Podolak for the score …. Very cool and old school. And, how about Donald Kaul? I’ve stolen his bits and jokes which, plagiarism, is the highest compliment one comedian can pay another.
I remember seeing reprints of the on-field racist assault of Drake star Johnny Bright when the Bulldogs played what is now Oklahoma State:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/e/e9/Johnny_Bright_Incident.jpg
As one who lived in central and western Iowa, when I went to Iowa City for college, I really only knew one newspaper–the Register. Over the years when I returned for a visit, the Register seemed to get thinner. Somewhere along the way, I discovered the Gazette online, became a fan and just got settled in when they started charging to log on. So, away I went for awhile, until I decided to take a look again a few years ago. Glad I did. Last time I was back home, I looked at a Register and was amazed by how little there was to it. I had heard the Gannett did a number on it but had no idea it was that bad.
As one who lives far away, I’ll support this paper, to the extent it helps, by checking in most days and giving an occasional comment here and there. I enjoy coming in , and hope The Gazette can hold the line. As Murrow said, Good Night and Good Luck.
I’m not surprised about the demise of the register….for a leading news paper in a leading agriculture state….they were sure anti agriculture….I quit reading them years ago….they also had 1-2 full pages of heavy duty truck advertisements and about 4-5pages of farm machinery ads…..it seemed like they priced them selves out of the picture….
Mike, I want to affirm what you guys are doing with the new-media stuff. I grew up in Iowa City so it was all Press-Citizen for me, with a little Des Moines Register. The Gazette was an afterthought. But since I’ve moved out of state, and have to rely on web-content for my Hawkeye news, you guys stand above the rest due to your blogs, webcasts, chats, and podcasts. Sorry I can’t add to your subscriber numbers, but I give you several page views a day.
Glass House Syndrome
If the glass house statement is referencing that you think that Mike Hlas is throwing stones, you are off base. No where did I see him say “The Register stinks and we are great”. He was simply stating a very obvious fact – the Register was at one time a leader, not only here in Iowa but across the country, and it is no more. I advertise in the Register and their staff has been cut time and time again. Hard to be a leader of anything on a skeleton crew.
So, Riell, re-read the post. Its an interesting microcosm of today’s world, not just here in Iowa but everywhere.
Dwight
Sorry, Mike is complaining about what Gannett has done to the Register by cutting talent and trying to adjust to the realities of the newspaper industry (it’s main readers are dying) and overly compensating those at the top. Can you really say the Gazette is any different? Clearly the content part of the Gazette product has suffered over the last several years and Gazette management is responsible for this. I want the Gazette to survive and thrive, I have two subscriptions and I advertise in the Gazette at times, but it is nowhere near the quality product that it used to be.
Enlighten the people, generally, and tyranny and oppressions of body and mind will vanish like spirits at the dawn of day. Thomas Jefferson
Interesting how a man of the enlightenment can be so very spot on and yet….
I do not take a single newspaper, nor read one a month, and I feel myself infinitely the happier for it. Thomas Jefferson.
News and newspapers have always been the basis of our democracy, when they get crappy, our democracy gets even worse, and those of the conservative mind set tend to see that as a positive. The less we know, the better, as far as they are concerned. Hence, “if it bleeds it leads.” Yellow journalism is alive and well, hopefully we will find a change from it once again and papers will go out on a limb for their circulation, do the investigative reporting and create the interest in a public forum to demand the answers from those responsible. We need the news, even if it hurts; when major disasters happen that affect the entire world, that story should not be buried after a couple of weeks! Japan’s nuclear disaster, for example, is continuing to pump radioactivity of all sorts into the atmosphere and it appears not to matter, how disgusting! Who are the news media serving by not doing their job? When you have the answer, you will know how far removed democracy has gotten from the people in this country. Newspapers are part of that equation.
Mike, One of the best articles you have written. It is sad to see the Register and also the Gazette go down hill but it is a sign of the times. I haven’t purchased a Gazette or Register in years and obtain all of my news via the internet. The Gazette’s website is great for keeping up with local news and the Hawkeyes.
Sad to say that the days of a cup of coffee and the Sunday paper are gone. Again thanks for the great article.
Because of the Internet, more people are reading newspapers. Unfortunately, it takes 22 online readers to produce the same revenue as one print reader. Newspaper executives haven’t figured out a way to make money in the digital age, and great writers like Keeler and Meisner are told to take a hike. Not only do they suffer as individuals, we the people lose out as well.