Jennifer Hemmingsen

I'm an op-ed columnist and member of The Gazette's editorial board, writing primarily about Iowa politics, social issues, public safety [...]
Updated: 22 June 2011 | 8:56 am in You are here by Jennifer Hemmingsen

Mount Vernon principal’s resignation isn’t the end of the story


thegazette.com Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Washington Elementary School principal Terry Eisenbarth’s resignation shouldn’t be the end of investigations into claims that he bullied students and staff.

For his sake and that of his current — and any future — students, school investigators and police need to get to the bottom of those allegations.

Iowa law allows the Mount Vernon school district to simply close the book on any investigation into Eisenbarth’s behavior now that the school board has his resignation in hand.

But if it’s true that Eisenbarth showed a pattern of misconduct, professional licensers should have the chance to review the facts and determine whether or not any sanctions are in order.

If allegations are unfounded, Eisenbarth deserves to have his name cleared — not to have to leave Mount Vernon under a cloud of suspicion.

Leaving the question unanswered shouldn’t be an option.

Mount Vernon School Board members had

barely convened a closed session last Friday to discuss Eisenbarth’s employment when they received the elementary school principal’s letter of resignation.

And while school board members didn’t explicitly say they considered the resignation the last word on allegations of harassment, bullying and safety issues that teachers say have gone unaddressed all year, their position was clear:

“We believe it is time to move forward,” Board President Tom Wieseler told dozens of concerned parents and community members who turned

out for the special meeting.

“Understand that there is no decision that the board can make that will satisfy everyone. There are no winners in this discussion.”

But resolving the allegations isn’t about winners and losers — it’s about discovering the truth and holding Eisenbarth accountable if he did show a pattern of unprofessional behavior.

In one way, Wieseler was right: There are no winners if school boards, so relieved to be rid of a problematic educator,

use resignations as excuses to drop misconduct

investigations like a student drops textbooks in June.

Even if their intent isn’t to shuffle incompetent or unethical educators along to other school districts, boards should know that’s what they’re making possible when they sweep dirt under the rug.

How many times do we have to learn this lesson: Until Iowa law changes to require districts to report serious allegations of misconduct to state licensers, there always will be school boards happy to close their eyes to their role in the problem.

Comments: (319) 339-3154; jennifer.hemmingsen@sourcemedia.net

Rules of Engagement
  • Be truthful. more
  • Be civil. more
  • Be responsible. more
  • Own your words. more
  • Leave the trolls alone. more
  • Take commercial ads elsewhere. more
  • Know that comments will be moderated. more
  • Or what? more
Mount Vernon principal’s resignation isn’t the end of the story
  1. Jennifer, I agreed 100% . . . . . . until your last sentence. That is the part that makes it unfair.

    I would strongly support a bill mandating all investigations must be completed, regardless of any change in employment status. But I would not mandate that unfounded allegations be reported to the Board of Educational Examiners.

    There are too many times parents make frivolous accusations when they get upset with a teacher (or a nurse, or a police officer) to require these be placed in a permanent personnel file; especially when one of the ongoing debates is allowing the general public access to this information.

    I would go so far as to require unfounded accusations to be purged from all personnel records.

  2. Jennifer, I have to criticize the news reporting of this story. In your opinion column, you went and actually talked to teachers at Washington, and unearthed allegations about Eisenbarth’s management.

    Yet, EVERY STORY in the news columns focused only on the birthday paddlings. To be blunt, I think the Gazette and other Eastern Iowa news outlets dropped the ball.

  3. Knowing full well the outcome of this issue will not be impacted by my words, I still feel it’s important for me to voice my opinion.
    I have known Terry Eisenbarth for several years, since he was the elementary principal at South Tama County.
    Terry introduced Character Counts at STC, and did so by example. He is a good father, husband and person in general
    I don’t know the extent of all the accusations, but I do know he would never jeprodize his own personal beliefs.
    I’m sure there were staff members and people he made “nervous.” He expects a certain level of behavior from those around him that not everyone is willing to live up to and that can cause friction.
    The kids at STC were very fond of him, and he of them. He treated them with respect and dignity.
    By the way, I am a 56 year old male and am proud to list Terry as one of my best friends.

    Charley Townsley




Featured Jobs from corridorcareers.com