
Caption: Iowa quarterback Ricky Stanzi (12) gets blocks from James Ferentz (53) and Julian Vandervelde (63) on Penn State's Ollie Ogbu (85) as he drops back to pass during the first half of their Big Ten Conference College Football Game Saturday, Oct. 2, 2010 at Kinnick Stadium in Iowa City. (Brian Ray/ SourceMedia Group News)
CHICAGO — Rules were the topic for the Tuesday morning session for football coaches at the Big Ten spring meetings.
The coaches emerged a bit grumpy and confused.
Two new rules hitting the books this fall have their attention — unsportsmanlike conduct for celebrating a touchdown before crossing the goal line and where and when cut blocks are illegal, a “drastic change,” Bill Carollo, the Big Ten’s coordinator of football officials, said.
The cut block change has caused quite a bit confusion. Listen Carollo describe it:
“We’ve basically gone to low blocks [cut blocks] are illegal now with these exceptions: Linemen on the line of scrimmage, they can cut block. Backs in the backfield who are stationary and between the tackles, they can cut low,” Carollo said. “Not only do we put the restriction on the low blocks on the offense, we’re now putting them on the defense.”
Wait, what? Defensive blocking penalties?
“Defensive linemen right at the snap, they can go low,” Carollo said. “A defensive back in press coverage, he can go low. A pulling guard, he also can go low.”
But what about players leaving the tackle box?
“Once the ball leaves the tackle box, that 6 [yards] by 10 area that’s defined, then the defense can’t cut block,” Carollo said. “So, it’s a huge learning curve for the coaches to teach the players and equally a huge learning curve for the officials.”
So, all low blocks are illegal outside of the tackle box and on the line of scrimmage for press defensive backs. This includes special teams (kick and punt return), change of possessions (fumbles and interceptions) and any defensive techniques that may include taking blockers out outside of the tackle box.
Chop blocks, when two O-linemen engage a D-lineman and one goes high while the other blocks low, has been and remains illegal, a 15-yard penalty. The new illegal block is 10 yards.
So, 12 grumpy Big Ten football coaches just saw some practice schedules go up in flames because of explanation of this new cut block rule.
“That was a big part of the morning this morning,” Iowa coach Kirk Ferentz said with a chuckle. “I think that’s going to be interesting. We have two major changes. . . . Cut blocking has changed. They have a little bit of a different slant on it now. It’s something that probably needs further discussion.”
Carollo admitted that there is a ton of learning on both sides of the game.
“Where did this guy start [line up before the play]?” Carollo asked. “I have my man on this side of the field, but the play ends up on the other side and he has a low block. So, now there’s a little more teamwork with the officials. Where did 87 start that play. Was he in motion or was he stationary? Being in motion, you’re pretty much restricted.
“You can always block low if you’re going north, south or away from the action to the sideline. That’s the major concern. I expect we’ll have a meeting with the rules editor this week. We’ll have a meeting in early June and we’re going to get a few of these things clarified.”
The coaches’ concern with the celebration penalty is what constitutes celebration. The “live ball” component of the rule, which was announced before last season and will be enacted this year, can take points off the board. It will be treated just like a holding penalty that took place during the play. The ball will be placed at the 20-yard line and the points will come off the board.
Start your somersault before you reach the goal line (Reggie Bush), the points will come off the board. If you flip into the end zone after you’ve crossed the goal line, it’s a deadball 15-yarder assessed on the kickoff or the PAT.
“The unsportsmanlike rule has the potential to be a steeper penalty,” Ferentz said. “I would imagine every coach is concerned and probably every official is concerned because of the subjectivity. I think we all can think of a play that took place a couple years ago [Reggie Bush] that was kind of a Kodak moment in that regard. It’s a little bit of a gray area.”
Carollo said officials and coaches will be shown videos of what constitutes a flag, but there certainly is room for some sort of new taunt that officials don’t even pick up on.
“If someone is doing something prolonged or exaggerated or drawing attention to himself, in the judgment of the official, there’s a good chance that he will get a flag for unsportsmanlike conduct,” said Carollo, a former NFL official. “The big change is that it will be a live ball [penalty] and we will take away touchdowns.”
The rule was introduced two years ago to brace schools for what’s considered unsportsmanlike. Still, there’s an interpretation to it and not everyone will know it when they see it.
There is so much room for error with these two changes I don’t know where to begin. I can sort of understand the unsportsmanlike penalty because players have some control over that but the cutblocking thing especially against the defense??!! That is a lot to ask from the officials IMHO.
I think it’s a relatively easy coaching point for D. Unless you’re in press coverage, don’t go low (of course, still legal when tackling).
I think the motion with slot receivers makes it tricky. I don’t like the passing of a player to another official (I think that’s basically what’s happening) during a play. Remember Glen Mason’s cut schemes at Minnesota, still would be legal.
I was hoping for some rule changes as some teams seem to enjoy using the blind cut block from behind against Iowa (Many against Clayborne last year) which are dangerous cheap shots that can ruin careers, but cut blocking against the defence? Looks like what may have been a good ideal by league officials got watered down so as not to look like their targeting any particular program. I really don’t care about players celebrating but man I hate to see those dangerous cut blocks. Players and coaches who teach them should be shunned by their peers and fans.
I think cut blocks are OK in a closed space (the line of scrimmage). A lineman diving at your legs is easier to deal with than a defensive back going full speed into your knees on an interception return. I think that’s the whole point here. The motion with slot receivers is going to get confusiing. I don’t think those players are allowed to cut block now, which makes sense because they have a running start.
While this statement is clear (“Once the ball leaves the tackle box, that 6 [yards] by 10 area that’s defined”), officials might be able to more consistently enforce this if they used the high school rule which basically says cuts are legal within the box and ONLY on the initial surge of the play. The above quote leaves room for doubt (and inconsistent application) if the ball doesn’t leave the area or if it comes close to leaving the area. Love the celebration rule, though.
I like the high school rule better. That would take out any interpretation on a slot receiver (or H-back) in motion. I probably shouldn’t throw H-back in there. Iowa doesn’t slide that second TE/H-back outside of the tackle box.
Paul Johnson just got a little crankier, and his wideouts are going to have a busy fall camp relearning how to block.