Mike Hlas

Hi, I'm Gazette/TheGazette.com sports columnist Mike Hlas. This is the Hlog. We will meet here, discuss things, and then go [...]
Updated: 31 January 2011 | 6:47 pm in The Hlog by Mike Hlas

This Iowa football rhabdomyolysis story is an enigma wrapped in a riddle


thegazette.com Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Since I don’t know what precisely went on at the University of Iowa football team’s workout of Jan. 20, all I can do is guess why all those players entered University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics a few days later.

So much for new revelations.

Sorry, but I’m about as much an expert on the unrest in Egypt as to pinpointing what led to the outbreak of rhabdomyolysis with the Hawkeyes. Opinions put out by others seem to be conflicting, to say the least.

I’ve been told the first thing some people in the strength and training communities have said about the story is “What are those guys taking?”

Then I read the Sunday press release from Iowa in which Coach Kirk Ferentz that said “They trained extremely hard and ended up in the hospital, and there is no indication they did anything wrong.”

I read the quote from now-former Hawkeye player Christian Ballard last week when he was in Alabama preparing for the Senior Bowl. “I don’t know all the details,” Ballard said, “but I’m pretty sure a few of them went out on the weekend, had a good time, the first weekend back at school instead of recovering and resting like they should have been doing.”

Then I wondered if any other players at Iowa or anywhere else had ever partied a bit before their first winter workouts and did come up with a firm answer. Namely, yes.

I saw the blistering ESPN.com essay last Friday by Pat Forde, who questioned Ferentz’s leadership, compassion and accountability.

Then I thought back to the last 12 years living in Iowa and covering Hawkeyes football, and remembering hearing one or two (thousand) comments from people with firsthand experience who would have told you there isn’t a thing to question in any of those qualities when it came to the coach.

By the way, if you’re a Hawkeye fan outraged at the way certain national columnists have treated your football coach and program in the last several days, ask yourself what your reaction would have been had this story belonged to an Alabama or USC or Ohio State instead.

Former Hawkeye players like Pat Angerer, Matt Bowen and Tyler Sash have rushed to the defense of Iowa strength and conditioning coach Chris Doyle, saying they went through his 100-squat January wake-up call and were better for it. “We all made it through it,” said Angerer.

Was this the Jan. 20 workout the same one as others in the past? To my knowledge, there hasn’t been a soul at that Iowa workout who has made a public statement about it. Whatever words that come from anyone at the university will be measured very carefully, understandably so.

Angerer credits Doyle for helping turn him from a marginal college recruit into an NFL player. He is one of a long line of ex-Hawkeyes in the pros who has publicly passed on praise and gratitude to Doyle, most of them having done so years before this bizarre story developed.

When Robert Gallery was in New York for the 2004 NFL draft, he paid for Ferentz, offensive line coach Reese Morgan and Doyle to be at the event with him.

Of course, you could flip things and say those who have made it to the pros would seem to be the most likely of all former players to support their college coaches.

See, you can talk around and around on this story, but you keep returning where you started. It’s maddening, because 13 players were in the hospital for something very serious. You want this to make some sense so it can be avoided in the future.

But it didn’t make sense at the time at McMinnville High School in Oregon last August when 13 football players were hospitalized for rhabdomyolysis after a strenuous preseason workout. It didn’t make sense at the University of South Carolina in 2007 when seven members of the University of South Carolina men’s and women’s swimming team were hospitalized for the same reason after a particularly demanding first practice of the season.

So given what we truly know about this story, are you sure you know what to think beyond what you may want to think? I’m not.

I guess I just can’t see going on either a witch hunt or  blind faith. It’s one of the darnedest stories we’ve ever had in my three decades at The Gazette.

Rules of Engagement
  • Be truthful. more
  • Be civil. more
  • Be responsible. more
  • Own your words. more
  • Leave the trolls alone. more
  • Take commercial ads elsewhere. more
  • Know that comments will be moderated. more
  • Or what? more
This Iowa football rhabdomyolysis story is an enigma wrapped in a riddle
  1. You nailed it or did you!??!?! Good stuff Mike, very hard to pinpoint and I can answer with a resounding “no” I would not been up in arms or bothered in the least had it happen in Alabama or Ames. I’m very well schooled in the be careful about throwing stones, and thngs are often not as they seem line of rationale.

    I’ve always been told, when you really don’t know, tread carefully, and even when you do know be careful of saying things you’ll regret later…..sometimes I fail, but these national pundits didn’t fail they did excatly what they meant to do.

    Chad

  2. I did a web search on rhabdomyolysis, and Google came up with a long list of potential causes …

    Risk factors include the following:

    •Alcoholism (with subsequent muscle tremors)
    •Certain inherited or genetic syndromes
    •Crush Injuries
    •Heat intolerance
    •Heatstroke
    •Ischemia or necrosis of the muscles (as may occur with arterial occlusion, deep venous thrombosis, or other conditions)
    •Low phosphate levels
    •Seizures
    •Severe exertion such as marathon running or calisthenics
    •Shaking chills
    •Trauma
    •Use or overdose of drugs, especially cocaine, amphetamines, statins, heroin, or PCP

    Given what we know (or don’t know), I’d have to go with “severe exertion such as marathon running or calisthenics” as a main cause. Add in one or two other factors (and subtract many!) and you can possibly see 13 of the overall list of football players [I'm not sure how many since we're between seasons] having a medical problem. Just guessing, but could the coaches have mentioned a number as a “goal,” and slightly out-of-condition players taken it as a “got to get to?”

  3. This has been a tough story Mike. Everyone is quick to point a finger. If its not at who is to blame for this happening, its at who is to blame for how the aftermath was handled.

    I have found it amusing how all of us who pose as football experts during the fall apparently have side jobs as media consultants, public relations gurus and medical personnel too boot. I predict soon we may show our legal expertise.

    • You’re killin’ me Garth! LMAO You are one of the reasons why I continue to visit this site. You scratch me right where I itch. :)

      • I’ve always been a psychology expert, even though I sloughed through the one psych class I took in college. I know human behavior, since I’ve spent my whole life behaving in different ways.

        As for law, medicine, finance and TV repair … I have to rely on the kindness of strangers.

        • Does anyone repair TV’s anymore Mike? LOL

          I as well only took one Psych class in college during my freshman year. The only part I liked was being part of the graduate students’ experiments. I like being poked and prodded (intellectually that is). :)

    • Don’t forget…..Psychologists and morality experts………….LOL!

      I learn a lot about my own failings on here more than anything I think.

      Chad

  4. Mike-
    You also questioned Coach’s and Barta’s accountability, so don’t act as though it was “those other writers” such as Forde and Doyel.

    • Jason:

      I questioned why they (and Barta) didn’t attend the press conference last week. Beyond that, I don’t think you can support your statement, though everything that’s written is subjective. And I stand by that. I think Ferentz and Barta in particular should have either been at the press conference or it shouldn’t have been held until they could make it.

      That, however, is part of the past and far from the main issue here.

      Go back to my original column on this matter after the press conference, and I used the “we don’t know” mantra there.

  5. Mike, I agree with Jason, et al, that you seemed to be always looking for someone to blame here. I believe we have a very special coach with very good assistants and a special guy in Doyle. It really bothered me that you always seem to be implying there was sometying wrong going on here. I think you should have waited for more data from the doctors, etc.
    Please show more respect for this program … which has been very successful.




Featured Jobs from corridorcareers.com