Scott Dochterman

I'm originally from Burlington, and I'm a 1997 Western Illinois University graduate. I've worked in Burlington, Muscatine, Fort Dodge and [...]
Updated: 23 December 2009 | 11:00 am in Doc's Office by Scott Dochterman, Hawkeye Football, Iowa Hawkeyes

What would a college football playoff look like? Here’s a glance


thegazette.com Copyright 2011 SourceMedia Group. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

2009-printable-ncaa-bracket-blankNothing in sports generates quite the polarizing buzz like the argument of keeping the current college football bowl system vs. adding a playoff system.

Most playoff scenarios center on incorporating the bowl system with the top eight teams in the country. Either one is ridiculous. Here’s why:

A playoff field must include home campuses. Bowls are struggling to sell tickets in a tough economy. Are you going to tell me that in an eight-team playoff that fans from let’s say, Iowa, could afford a quarterfinal bowl game in Dallas, a semifinal in Phoenix and a championship game in Pasadena? That’s not realistic. NCAA Tournament basketball games involving teams that sell out their arenas often play before half-empty crowds halfway across the country.  The first time Oregon and Ohio State play a football quarterfinal in the Rose Bowl before 50,000 or fewer fans would be the last time.

Four/eight teams is not enough to stave off a lawsuit. What happens if a four-team playoff leaves off an unbeaten Boise State? What happens if an eight-team playoff excludes the Big Ten or ACC champion? You know that game would be coming to a courtroom near you.

If the NCAA sanctions a tournament-style postseason, it would need to be a comprehensive, 24-team playoff with elements of the NCAA basketball tournament. It would need to have four regions consisting of six teams with the top two receiving byes. It would need to include every conference champion (11) and all BCS conferences’ second-best teams based on BCS rankings (six). The final seven spots would be selected strictly on BCS rankings regardless of conference or independent status with no more than four schools qualifying from one conference.

The eight byes would be determined from straight BCS rankings. The final 16 tournament spots would be arranged by a committee with decisions based on strength and geography, as long as one region does not contain two teams from the same conference. The tournament would be bracketed, and the highest seed would host all games until national semifinals, which then would be held at a neutral site.

Here’s how a 24-team bracket would look, based on that criteria:

SOUTH REGION

  • Byes: (1) Alabama, (2) Ohio State
  • First round match-ups: (6) Troy at (3) Georgia Tech; (5) Oregon State at (4) Pittsburgh
  • South champion vs. Central champion

WEST REGION

  • Byes: (1) Texas, (2) Oregon
  • First-round match-ups: (6) Central Michigan at (3) Iowa; (5) East Carolina at (4) BYU
  • West champion vs. East champion

EAST REGION

  • Byes: (1) Cincinnati, (2) Boise State
  • First-round match-ups: (6) Stanford at (3) LSU; (5) Miami at (4) Penn State
  • East champion vs. West champion

CENTRAL REGION

  • Byes: (1) TCU, (2) Florida
  • First-round match-ups: (6) Oklahoma State at (3) Virginia Tech; (5) Arizona at (4) West Virginia
  • Central champion vs. South champion

The four teams on the bubble out based on this criteria include Nebraska, USC, Utah and Wisconsin.

Sounds crazy? Yes, a little bit. Personally, I’m a bowl guy. But if the bowls eventually are discarded, this is the best route to go.

Rules of Engagement
  • Be truthful. more
  • Be civil. more
  • Be responsible. more
  • Own your words. more
  • Leave the trolls alone. more
  • Take commercial ads elsewhere. more
  • Know that comments will be moderated. more
  • Or what? more
What would a college football playoff look like? Here’s a glance
  1. The Division II schools have done this for years. Television money could make up for the fan base. A 16 team playoff would work, 24 as you have would be good but would include many teams who don't deserve to play, it would make the regular season almost irrelevant, unless you drew a bye.

  2. It would be nice if the printable bracket would open to a bigger window.

  3. It should be just like the division UNI plays in. It works just fine there and no one complains. They are even moving their championship game into January next year.

    And people can ask, would fans in the northern states really show up and fill stadiums in December and January??? What do you think. How we would love to get our hands on a warm weather team in Kinnick in late December / January. And the NFL has no problems filling outdoor stadiums in the same months in northern states. The BCS boys better get on board before they get run right over. Need to put them up on the Kinnick jumbo screen with the Metallica playing and the truck running them over.

  4. I'm not sure why we need to say that 8 isn't enough, then jump to 24. I think 16 would be a good number. And technically, you could still keep some of the bowls intact for non-playoff teams, they'd just be even more like post season "exhibitions."

  5. Hi yall I just wanted to ask everybody out there stop by http://www.helphaitinow.org

  6. So very glad I found this truly great site

  7. Nice Website. You should think more about RSS Feeds as a traffic source. They bring me a nice bit of traffic.

  8. I very much enjoy your blog posts, thank you very much you have helped me out greatly :) love lots.

  9. Visits always give pleasure if not the arrival the departure.

  10. Thanks-a-mundo for the article post. Great.

  11. Various people in the world take the business loans in various banks, because this is simple and comfortable.

  12. Aw, this was a really quality post. In theory I’d like to write like this too – taking time and real effort to make a good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and never seem to get something done.

  13. I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.

  14. Terrific piece of writing, I share the same views. I wonder why this important entire world truly does not feel similar to me personally and the blog creator :-)

  15. Eye-popping post, I share the same views. I wonder why this particular the entire global population does indeed not think just like me personally in addition to the blog website creator :-)

  16. that’s incredible.

  17. Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write in my site something like that. Can I take part of your

  18. your site came up.

  19. Thank you for a great post

  20. Thanks for the good read. I extremely enjoyed it! I don’t usually comment on blogs but this one really was interesting. I will bookmark for later.

  21. Wonderful to read!

  22. Decent site. Great on-line affiliate program. Thank you.

  23. Great advice! Loyalty shouldn’t be underestimated. Too often, it’s taken for granted. In the long run, hard work doesn’t go unrewarded.

  24. Beneficial Write-up! My spouse and i was just reasoning that there is a bunch awry related information within the topic area and you also just simply adjusted my husband and my thought. Appreciate your sharing a beautiful site.

  25. Even a pro blogger, they still using those tips =D

  26. Wonderful piece of data that you’ve received on this website submit. Hope I could possibly get some additional of the stuff on your own weblog. I will occur again.

  27. thanks for this lovely post …

  28. Of course, what a great site and informative posts, I will add backlink – bookmark this site? Regards,

  29. Phenomenal, thanks for posting!

  30. This is getting a bit more subjective, but I much prefer the Zune Marketplace. The interface is colorful, has more flair, and some cool features like ‘Mixview’ that let you quickly see related albums, songs, or other users related to what you’re listening to. Clicking on one of those will center on that item, and another set of “neighbors” will come into view, allowing you to navigate around exploring by similar artists, songs, or users. Speaking of users, the Zune “Social” is also great fun, letting you find others with shared tastes and becoming friends with them. You then can listen to a playlist created based on an amalgamation of what all your friends are listening to, which is also enjoyable. Those concerned with privacy will be relieved to know you can prevent the public from seeing your personal listening habits if you so choose.

  31. Good ideas there. Congrats on getting linked from ProBlogger! Keep up the good work.

  32. I find your blog in google. And I will be back next time, thanks.

  33. I really enjoyed visiting your blog, and it looks wonderful. If you get a chance you should visit my site as well. I hope you have a great day!

  34. Hoeveel kan ik lenen? (hypotheek). Wat worden mijn maandlasten? (hypotheek) … Hoeveel hypotheek heb ik nodig? Hoe hoog is de boete die ik nu zou moeten

  35. Hypotheken? Heel veel hypotheek informatie: verschillende hypotheekvormen, hypotheekrentes, nationale hypotheek garantie, hoe een hypotheek te vergelijken.

  36. Thanks for taking the time to write that, I found it very interesting. If you get a chance you should visit my blog as well. I hope you have a great day!

  37. Im going to tell you now, I believe im adding you to my favorite writers list. This is such a great post and really hit the nail on the head for me. Please keep it up. Your readers thank you.

  38. Over de voor- en nadelen van het afsluiten van een lening zonder BKR-toetsing.

  39. BKR problemen? Nu Geld lenen zonder BKR toetsing? Op zoek naar betrouwbare aanbieders? Wij vergelijken banken die u toch kunnen helpen aan een betrouwbare

  40. Superb article ,I really appreciated with it, This is finicky to read and valuable on behalf of outlook,I really bookmark it, on behalf of expand read. Credit on behalf of sharing.I like it.

  41. I really liked reading your site, and it looks outstanding. If you get a chance you should check my blog as well. I hope you have a good day!

  42. Migraine is een ernstige vorm van hoofdpijn. Het treedt in aanvallen op en gaat vaak gepaard met visuele stoornissen en misselijkheid.

  43. Hoewel migraine op elke leeftijd voor het eerst kan optreden, begint dit type hoofdpijn meestal tussen de tien en veertig jaar. Bij de meeste mensen treedt

  44. I happened upon this site totally by accident when I was looking for something else totally unrelated. I hear the best things in life are accidents though and this site is no exception. Please keep up the great work as I plan to look for your website daily.

  45. Why does this wasn’t available in the search I made for some time ago, this website is awesome, thanks a lot guys!

  46. Simply cool information you have published here, this is awesome, please keep updating this website Im learning lots here.

What would a college football playoff look like? Here’s a glance

1 Trackback




Featured Jobs from corridorcareers.com